Jane Eyre

Originally published on social media on March 6th, 2023

This review will apply not to just this adaptation of Jane Eyre’s, but all Jane Eyres.

Back in high school, I was like one of the only students who read this book all the way through. I enjoyed it and loved being introduced to a world of literature I had never known. Since those days, I’ve only spoken about how much I like this film and the book…only I hadn’t actually touched it since that time. Now here I am over 10 years later and I have some thoughts.

Why are high schools requiring this book? If I were to introduce students to period dramas or comedies, why not go for a Jane Austin classic that is just as good of quality but more hope? Students need hope right now, not negativity or toxic masculinity.

That’s right…toxic masculinity. I used to think Mr. Rochester was a hunk, but now that I have some real world experience, I recognize what a demeaning, manipulative, cowardly, egotistical creep he is. He consistently messes with Jane’s feelings and mind. Yes, men did not believe in gender equality back then…but it does not make Mr. Rochester’s style of gaslighting acceptable. We do not need to encourage young men to become like Mr. Rochester.

What we should encourage in men are characteristics embodied by John Rivers who helps Jane when she is in need without treating her like charity. John Rivers listens to Jane, values Jane as a human being and woman, and helps her gain employment. These are the kind of men the world needs: men who can lend a hand, listen, and be kind and generous. Men who are willing to partner with women rather than assert power over them.

Jane Eyre herself is resilient, consistently rising above the challenges she faces. That is a great message to teach young people…that you can be strong in the midst of adversity. However, I would rather pick up a Jane Austin novel than Jane Eyre any day. Austin mocks and points out the flaws in the selfish and the manipulative, where Eyre (or better yet Charlotte Brontë) will only accept that’s how humanity is. I choose Austin.

Never be afraid to change your mind or revisit things from the past. You never know what you’ll discover or learn about yourself or the world.